The house had benefited from only a few careful owners, but Randall and Judy knew it needed a bit more love.
"The front four rooms are virtually original," Randall says. "They're all 13-foot [4m] studs with five different patterns of pressed tin ceilings."
The hallway's elaborate arch and pillars, and the carved corner fireplaces, hark back to a more gracious era. Those tall square bays feature in the front living room and master bedroom next door, with two more large bedrooms across the hall.
Beyond the elegance of the front four rooms, older renovations at the rear of the house were a bit tired. "The bones were great," says Judy, "with the sunny windows and sea views." Not so great was the room-darkening cork floor and timber joinery.
"It made such a difference painting everything white and opening up the western wall with sliders," she says. Judy claims it's the sunniest house she's ever lived in, tracking the sun from the living area's bay window: morning coffee, sunny winter reading nook, evening glass of wine watching the harbour.
The couple were experienced planners so specified a classic panelled kitchen, packed with storage. "I can be cutting veges and look up to see a yacht race on the harbour," Judy says. The marble waterfall benches give way to stainless steel in the clever butler's pantry.
Two upstairs bathrooms have benefited from their touch, too. They slotted in a light-filled en suite with double shower, while a generous family bathroom was reclaimed from a back porch, with its own harbour views from the sculptural bathtub.
More dramatic changes took place on the lower level. The wide, shaded upstairs veranda has stairs to the lower decks and a transformed garden. Randall trucked in 300cu m of scoria, sand and soil to create a level drained lawn, so that puppy got the best playground in town.
A heated pool surrounded by decks keeps his people and their friends happy, too.
Inside, the Wulffs have streamlined a warren of downstairs rooms into a family area with separate entry and lots of potential uses. A remnant of the house's past as the Mercury Theatre's storage and "party house" is now a separate media room, complete with vintage Air NZ first-class seats. New French doors from the spacious games room blur indoor and outdoor entertainment options.
One large bedroom has its own generous en suite, and adding a double-size salvaged window created another light-filled garden bedroom. A marble-topped laundry could become a kitchenette, plus there's masses of storage and a separate toilet handy for swimmers.
Twin peaks on the double garage reflect the street's character and conceal yet more storage and workrooms below.
With this old lady's heritage restored, Randall and Judy can now contemplate another project in their favourite part of Herne Bay.