Both cars were badly damaged, with Featherston volunteer fire crew using chains and their truck to haul the cars off the road.
Mr Lindsay, who was on his way to Waikanae to visit family, said he was "a bit shaken up".
The other driver, a woman, had minor injuries and was taken by ambulance to Wairarapa Hospital.
On Monday morning around 8am a north-bound driver apparently opted to veer off SH2 into a shelter belt south of Masterton to avoid a potential nose-to-tail.
Carterton fire chief Wayne Robinson said it appeared a vehicle in front of the driver had suddenly slowed down.
Instead of hitting the vehicle, he swerved left, embedding the car in a shelter belt and fence just south of the Ravensdown entranceway.
"He probably did the right thing by veering off."
He said the man had some minor chest injuries from the seatbelt. He was seen by Wellington Free Ambulance staff. "It's that time of year - we had all that fine weather, and now the roads are really greasy."
The MetService forecast is for rainy weather into Good Friday.