"Then there is the likes of Sir Brian Lochore, who played his rugby here and lives in our district.
"Icons like these should be on some sort of register," Mr Caffell said.
Councillor Jonathan Hooker questioned whether it was "politic" to name streets after living people "or do you wait until they have died?"
Mayor Lyn Patterson said in previous cases it has always been the right of the developer to name new streets and put them to council for approval.
She said in light of the issues raised council officers would look at the naming policy and report to the full council meeting on December 10 when the question of naming streets for the two new subdivisions would again be discussed.