Monica said she didn't dwell on her award at the time, but she did find it "pretty disconcerting to know that there was a roomful of second years objectifying and labelling us, largely on appearances. What's more, the second years know that the practice is discriminatory, so they use code words for our labels. You get stood up, and potentially shamed, in front of your entire hall and you don't even know why ... It's a totally unnecessary, disingenuous, and generally unkind practice."
"Animal Channel" was an award which was typically given to shy or awkward students, and several former students identified it as particularly problematic. One student, who was given the Animal Channel award several years ago said "I thought it was really cool at the time, I didn't realise until later that they were making fun of me". Another ex-student described the award as "straight up bullying".
A female student from 2014 raised concerns about the power imbalances between first and second years, saying that the second years "have an inappropriate amount of power to affect the freshers ... the freshers desperately want to be noticed so most of them enjoy being picked but the point is that the freshers don't know what these stand for until they find a second-year willing to tell them".
"They mix all the harsh shit in with other light-hearted stuff and jokes and announcements and speeches so you don't notice so much how bad some of it is until you look back. Thinking about it now it seems so weird and childish."
Some former students defended the practice. A male student from 2015 and 2016 described it as "All in pretty good taste. No one got mad about it; it's just another fun little tradition." A female student from 2016 and 2017 said "the second years choosing the awards are careful not to select people who might feel uncomfortable in order to keep it light-hearted and joking in manner. It is not an exercise in humiliation or embarrassment."
The Selwyn College Board of Governors Chairman Aaron Douglas told The Critic that "We are not aware of this being a current practice, however we will look into this. Neither the University of Otago nor the Selwyn College Board of Governors condones this type of behaviour in any way and will look into this matter during semester two, after staff and students have returned to the college".
A spokeswoman for Otago University said the university was working with the Selwyn Student Association committee to ensure no inappropriate traditions were continued. The current student president was supportive of this, the university said.
"The Selwyn board is grateful previous college residents have had the courage to speak out about alleged inappropriate behaviour perpetuated at student events.
"We have a zero tolerance to bullying of any form.
"We want the best for the former residents who have come forward and sincerely hope that they contact us to discuss their concerns."
This story originally appeared on The Critic and has been republished here with permission.
