Dan Carter's underwear commercials were not enough to convince New Zealand women, with more saying they would prefer to spend a weekend with Richie McCaw.
A survey conducted by an Australian accommodation website asked more than 3000 people who would be their favourite All Black to go on holiday with for a weekend.
The findings found that 39 per cent of women picked the All Black captain, while 29 per cent chose Carter.
Wotif.com spokeswoman Megan Magill, said: "Dan Carter might be a heart-throb with the ladies but it seems all Kiwis are pretty loyal to the beloved All Blacks captain."
Only 10 per cent of New Zealand women said they would select Sonny Bill Williams if they had their pick of the All Blacks.