Potential discrepancies in the complainant’s statements were probed by counsel Sarah Saunderson-Warner.
“It’s different to what you said back then,” she said.
“What you are doing is making out to this jury that this was sexualised touching, when it wasn’t anything of the sort.”
The woman said she had “blocked out a lot of things that are now coming to light” and she had matured significantly since her first disclosure of the alleged abuse.
In opening last week, prosecutor Craig Power outlined the Crown’s case, telling the jury about the detailed allegations of prolonged sexual abuse against the two complainants.
He told the jury the man had preyed on his two stepdaughters for about eight years, even burning one of them with a cigarette.
A picture of the alleged injury was provided to the jury, but Saunderson-Warner said the wound could have been caused by anything.
“Are you a doctor?” she asked the complainant.
“You didn’t mention anything when you first talked to police, did you?”
Saunderson-Warner suggested the woman’s mother had instructed her children to concoct the allegations in order to have fulltime care of the girls.
“She had sowed the seed of being sexually abused by your stepfather ... you gave in to what she wanted,” she said.
The complainant disagreed.
“I simply told her the truth after I was an inconsolable mess in front of my younger siblings,” she said.
The trial is expected to last the remainder of the week and the complainant’s cross-examination will continue today.
erin.cox@odt.co.nz , PIJF court reporter
