"Well, it's just never good luck is it?"
The group was fortunate to have among its members Dr Ann Sprague, a retired University of Arizona planetary scientist who studied light data from Mars and already had connections with Dr Vilas and Dr Consolmagno.
"So we did have an in there, but then it's not just about having a contact -- it's that these people have to actually be willing to come, and they're even paying for themselves to come here," Somerville-Ryan said.
"Partly I think it was the attraction of people being able to come to a small isolated community, where we are desperate for knowledge, basically."
The Hauraki Gulf island, accessible only by plane or ferry, was well served with most amenities, "but mind-wise, it's a bit harder".
She was inspired by a festival that began in Canada 20 years ago, where a scientific topic was explored from different angles.
Last year's inaugural event focused on pandemics, and attracted a virologist, a Civil Defence expert and a science fiction writer.
"It was so successful that everyone just said, when's the next one?"
Again, the festival would address the topic from four perspectives: where did life come from, how does humanity fit into the universe, why do aliens appear the way they do in film, and how are we searching for other lifeforms?
"You can cover a lot of different angles, all with the purpose of providing education that meets a lot of peoples' interests."
The group also persued directors Sir Peter Jackson and James Cameron, but were unable to land them.
Still, she expected the talent on offer in September would more than satisfy locals.
"It's amazing. We're extremely privileged."
Along with the main panel discussion, the festival would involve breakout sessions and an art exhibition and book month event at the local library.
The Auckland Astronomical Society also plans to run an educational programme on the island during the week, giving local school students and adults the chance to see the stars through an eight-inch telescope.
Small island, big names
• Brother Guy Consolmagno: an astronomer, Jesuit Brother, director of the Vatican Observatory and president of the Vatican Observatory Foundation. He'll discuss the interface between science and humanity, exploring such issues as our place in the universe and what it would mean to us if life was found out there.
• Dr Faith Vilas: Project scientist at the United States Planetary Science Institute, who directs a National Science Foundation programme in charge of solar system and exoplanets grants. She'll discuss the search for life in the stars, where we are looking, how we are looking and what we are looking for.
• Gino Acevedo: Creative art director and textures head of department at Weta Digital, who worked on Avatar, King Kong, The Hobbit and Lord of The Rings. He'll speak about the human imagination when it comes to aliens, discussing what makes aliens friendly or fierce and why we depict them as we do.
• Professor Steve Pointing: An Auckland University of Technology microbiologist who has worked with Nasa in researching extreme lifeforms that can survive in polar cold and desert heat. His research and fascination with astrobiology has given insights into how life might exist on other planets.