I didn't do a head count, but there were a lot of folks standing and all the people crammed into St Matthew-in-the-City yesterday would surely have made the upstairs bar at the Gluepot feel pretty cosy.
Dave was up the front, centre stage and silent for a change rather than stage right where he always used to prowl, his guitar slung low, looking impossibly relaxed and cool. His coffin was a box of plain pine, still smelling from the woodwork shop, but adorned with words and images put there by those who knew him well and loved him most: the tributes mixed the solemn and the whimsical but all were heartfelt.
There was more than a sprinkling of one-time household names among the mourners. Musos aplenty, of course, the ones of the old school who paid their dues humping speakers and drum kits up back staircases, not the instant stars of reality TV.
It was one of those occasions when almost every face was familiar, even if the names didn't come too readily to ancient memories. Some, not seen since Sailor's early days, looked in pretty poor nick, until you remembered that you don't look quite as flash yourself as you did in 1977.
Unlike many who were there, I didn't know Dave particularly well. Occasionally we'd see each other at the Shakespeare, the pub over the road from the Herald building, where he was fond of taking the international students he taught English to for an end-of-term drink. He'd greet me enthusiastically, talk to me like an old friend and I'd wonder what I'd done to get such attention.
And yesterday made it plain: Dave treated everyone that way. When you talked to him, it was like you were the only person in the world. Sailor bassist Paul Woolright stood by Dave's coffin and remembered how he'd greeted Paul's teenage son when they'd shared a car together: possibly the coolest dude in Auckland music - "a handsome groovster" his daughter Moana called him - treated this gawky youth like he was the most important man in the world and the boy-turned-man has never forgotten.
Among the tributes, that of Dave's wife Donna stood out, and not just because it was the last. Supported by Peter Urlich, she sniffed through a lovingly crafted few hundred words that were the work of a gifted writer reaching right inside her soul. It was hard not to see Dave behind her, smiling lightly, urging her on.
But Lyon ruled out the idea of endless encores. The floor would not be thrown open to all-comers to have a say, he announced early on. It was a piece of tight production instinct that Dave would have loved. Always leave them wanting more.
Everyone was invited to Sale St, an easy stroll even for the most elderly relic, to have a drink and share stories. Chances are they're still there now, if you want to join them.