"The team did not have any luck refloating the orca last night," said DoC Whanganui spokeswoman Jasmine Hessel.
DoC has urged the public to "stay away from a health and safety point of view", the central north island duty officer told the Herald last night.
A picture on Facebook taken last night showed about a dozen people trying to help the whale. Many were digging with spades and some were carrying buckets of water to splash over the whale.
Inspector Ross Grantham said the whale had been stranded since just before 8pm and police were called by DoC to help manage the growing crowd.
The plan was for DoC to use a large digger to create a trench in front of the whale, using the incoming tide to flood the trench and allow her to float and make her way back out to sea, he said.
He thanked people for responding to a call on social media for people with wetsuits to come down to the beach.
Local woman Conna Smith, whose husband Nick was still at the beach after 11pm helping dig the trench for the whale, said before DoC and emergency services arrived the community was pitching in to try and help dig the whale out.
"It was a good community effort, people were just turning up with their spades, it was hard work. When one person got tired another person would take their spade and keep digging."
The whale was not moving or making much noise, which made Mrs Smith wonder if she could be sick, or perhaps just tired.
Mrs Smith's mother, Verna Bourke, said fire services had brought a generator to the beach which pumped seawater on to the Orca to keep her wet.