Living in a semi-rural part of West Auckland, Scotti had not checked the mail since the day before.
She said the thief either followed the courier van and saw the package being delivered or waited until nightfall and peered through the slit to see if there was something inside.
"[I feel a] little bit vulnerable, I guess because we don't live where we can see our letterbox. We were about 400 metres off the road. And also it's a really exposed area on the road. So, you know, it took somebody who really was interested in pursuing their endeavour to get there."
Scotti had no joy with New Zealand Post, which said that although her parcel was tracked, it was not delivered by a courier who would have brought the item to her door.
She now had a new letterbox which her husband had bolted securely to the post.
Others in her part of the Waitākere Ranges had also noticed goods ordered online going missing.
"About a month later, there were a couple of comments about [people] seeing someone wandering down one of the side streets carrying an item that people had been reported as not being delivered to their house and some you know, just strange people hanging about and looking at letterboxes," Scottie said.
New mother Jaime Belsar, from Christchurch, was targeted three times in just one week.
One case involved a pair of merino booties which were stolen from her unlocked mailbox.
She was home when they were delivered but by the time she went to get them they were gone. Belsar believes they would have been stolen with within the space of just nine minutes.
"My understanding is that they follow the couriers on bikes or in cars and just as soon as the courier turns the corner they just jump in and grab it," Belsar explained
"It's actually quite nerve-racking because our property isn't down a long driveway. We're right on the street. So knowing that somebody is out front right near our house, stealing things when it's me at home with my baby, it's actually quite scary."
She has now bought a lockable mailbox.
"So just be vigilant. This is actually happening so if you do have an authority to leave make sure you've got a secure letterbox or get it redirected to your work if you're not at home," Belsar said.
A police spokesperson said people should ensure they were home when goods were being delivered and if they could not then they should arrange to pick them up from a depot.
They asked for any suspicious behaviour such as cars following courier vans to be reported to them.
A New Zealand Post spokesperson said people could direct couriers to leave items in a safe place or ask to pick them up from a mail centre.
They advise people to put a lock on their letterboxes.
- RNZ