Lightning strikes late on Saturday were so severe they shook his Te Awamutu farmhouse.
But he thought they had escaped the worst of it until he went to bring his herd of 135 cows in for milking early on Sunday morning.
"I opened the gate and saw one cow tipped over, and I thought it might have got a fright from the lightning or got jammed in the fence"' he said.
"But as I went further into the paddock I saw more and more and wondered where it was going to end to be honest."
The storm tore through Wellington on Friday night, bringing about 800 lightning strikes in a three-hour period, MetService said.
Federated Farmers said while electrical storms occasionally kill stock, it is unusual that nine cows would perish at once.
"It's just really unlucky and can be pretty distressing," said adverse events spokeswoman, Katie Milne.
"It happens from time to time. Anecdotally, my great-grandfather had a bunch of hereford cattle standing under a tree in south Westland years ago and lost quite a number.
"There can be big trees or powerpoles around, or other times, there can be no reason at all why it chose to earth where the animals are. It really is in the hands of the Gods."
Mr Brown certainly hadn't seen anything like it in 26 years of farming.
"You hear of these stories, and you know it happens - lightning has to come down somewhere - but you never expect it to happen to yourself," the married father-of-three said.
"But that's life, isn't it. As sad a day as it is, life goes on."
The carcasses are "good for nothing", he said, and have already been removed to be processed for blood and bone.
Their market rate was between $1500 to $2000 per beast, he said.
"I was a bit short as it was this year, so it's left us in a bit of a hole."
Insurance doesn't cover his stock.
"I think there is a policy where you can insure your stock, but I imagine it's pretty expensive," Mr Brown said. "And you don't expect things like this to happen."
However, he's been buoyed by support from local farmers.
One friend has already offered him three cows, while a stock agent called in this morning to say someone else wanted to donate a cow.
"That's pretty awesome."