"I was really lucky to have, actually, very supportive, hard-working and loving parents. But I know, actually, most gay men, as they're growing up, I certainly felt maybe a sense of disappointment from Dad. He always wanted that First XV rugby player, and I was happier with my nose in a book or perhaps helping Mum in the kitchen with some cooking. So I knew I wasn't that person, and that sense of disappointment that kids are very sensitive to, it can be a little bit damaging."
He told Q&A that he was particularly concerned about the effect of Tamaki's comments of young people growing up in the provinces.
"It's actually throwing petrol on a fire when you send out a message that gay people are very similar to murderers, they're sinners, and they're creating natural disasters. You and I can dismiss that as intelligent adults as just being ludicrous, but for those kids, that's actually a really hurtful thing at an already difficult time in their life."
Before entering politics Foster-Bell was a diplomat, including postings to Saudi Arabia and Iran.
He said if he was openly gay in such places as a diplomat he would need to leave the country, but the person he was with would be a criminal.
"That person could be executed, have parts amputated. It's horrific the treatment of gay people in some countries of the world. So that was a challenge, and that's why for that part of my career I was discreet. That was a necessary level of discretion," he told Q&A.
"But it is worrying when you think if there was a possibility you might fall in love with somebody and that could lead to that person being killed or imprisoned. It's a huge worry."
Foster-Bell said he had held back from taking things further with people he cared for while working as a diplomat, something he said was heart-breaking.
The MP, who said he had been dating someone for about nine months, didn't expect his interview to cause any great surprise to those who knew him in Wellington - he is the vice-patron of Rainbow Wellington, for example. But he said he wanted the message out beyond the capital's "bubble".
"The Opposition have a number of gay MPs, but, actually, it's important that within the team that's running the country we also have that community represented, and I want to take a leadership role there."
In June, Foster-Bell made headlines after facing accusations of poor management after reportedly having 12 staff leave over a period of three years. His relatively high travel and accommodation bill also came under scrutiny.
He now faces a challenge to be National's Wellington Central candidate next year, with a former senior advisor to Prime Minister John Key confirming she will seek the party's nomination, which opens in January.
Nicola Willis currently holds a senior position at Fonterra, and worked for Key from 2006-2011.
Asked in the Q&A interview if that looming challenge contributed to his decision to speak out, Foster-Bell said he had been thinking about going public for more than a year.