It's the question of the week.
What are your plans for children, do you want kids, will you have kids, or a variation of the aforementioned and, oh my God, all hell breaks loose.
There are two parts to the question of whether it should have been asked of the new Labour leader.
You might have noticed I didn't raise the subject at all. Why? Because it wasn't remotely important enough or relevant enough on day one of a job that had vastly more matters to be discussed, like policy and polls and the future of the party in an election seven weeks away.
So you could perhaps argue the timing of the question was inappropriate. And given the timing was inappropriate, it gave rise to the massive amount of fall-out that ensued.