But the spot was clearly risky - two separate groups later got into trouble there, and two people were taken to hospital, Harvey said.
“The first group was warned about where they were, and that it was dangerous, and that person was rescued and brought back to the clubhouse, and then taken away by an ambulance.
“After patrol, we also had another group jump in the exact same place.
“They were able to get themselves back to shore, but they were also very unwell, and one of them had to go to hospital as well.”
The abuse was making lifeguards rethink their choice to volunteer and help the public, Harvey said.
“If you’re getting this flak from just people that you’re trying to keep safe, it’s very hard to keep on coming back day after day, week after week.”
And the Karioitahi club was already struggling for numbers, he said.
“It’s quite a worrying thing that with the growing population we have, that we might not be able to keep up with that.”
Harvey had a simple message for swimmers.
“When the flags are up, we want you guys in the water, if the flags are down, we want you to stay out.
“It’s just the safest thing, if you want to go home to your families every day, you listen to the lifeguards and you do what we tell you to, pretty much.”
- RNZ