The Labour Party wants farmers and other large-scale water users to pay a "resource rental charge" so the taxpayer isn't saddled with a $500 million tab for funding new irrigation schemes and for cleaning up polluted waterways.
But although the party says it wants to work with farmers on the proposal, Federated Farmers has already reacted angrily, dismissing it as an "ill-conceived" plan for a "punitive" tax, even though Labour has not said how much the charge would be.
Labour's policy would make regional councils responsible for allocating water rights under a system in which "water goes to the best uses rather than to who applies first".
But a "fair price" in the form of a resource rental would be charged to big water-users including farmers and industries to "encourage wise use of water and its allocation for higher-value uses".
Party water spokesman Brendan Burns said the plan was not a revenue-gathering exercise but an "economic and environmental tool" which would also alleviate the burden on taxpayers.