Philip Murray Kinraid unsuccessfully appealed his prison term with the Court of Appeal but has not ruled out appealing to the Supreme Court. Photo / Sam Hurley
A Taranaki man who killed his 2-year-old daughter has lost an appeal against his prison sentence, while certain facts about the horrific case remain suppressed.
He appealed the term of imprisonment, claiming it was "manifestly excessive".
However, the appeal was dismissed.
After the release of the Court of Appeal's decision yesterday, a judgment allowed the publication of certain facts pertaining to the prosecution against Kinraid.
"The horror that Esme must've felt in the last minutes of her life when her face was held into the pillow and her life taken away," he said.
"There is no doubt in her last minutes she experienced true horror."
Justice Ellis said the cause of Esme's death was a "fatal neck compression".
"A grown man holding a child down against her will. I do not accept what [Kinraid] did was not violent ... she was struggling against [him], she had no chance of escape.
"Esme is dead, her life and her future were taken away in an instant."