It is not just a bollocking, The (now former) Department of Labour has copped a right royal bollocking from the Royal Commission on the Pike River tragedy.
The department therefore has to take its share of the responsibility for the disaster. And thus by implication so does the Minister.
The report's criticism is so severe that Kate Wilkinson could not have stayed in the portfolio. The question is whether she should be gone from the Cabinet altogether - real punishment, rather than merely losing a portfolio.
Amazingly, Wilkinson barely gets a mention in the Commission's report.
When the report does mention her, it is to commend her for setting up a dedicated high-hazard inspectorate for the mining and petroleum industries post-tragedy.