Fuel tax increases are regressive. If National proposed tax reform where, as a share of income, the wealthy paid less and the poor paid more, Labour would be in revolt. And rightly so.
New Zealanders expect fairness in their tax system. We don't suffocate the rich, but we certainly expect our tax system to be fair. Poorer communities and families shouldn't be disproportionately punished by the tax system.
Yet, that appears to be the result of Phil Twyford's new regional and national fuel taxes.
Twyford's argument, reported by Simon Wilson in the Herald today, is that fuel taxes are easier on the poor, because poor people don't spend as much on fuel in dollar terms.
But looking at these same figures as a proportion of people's actual earnings tells a different story.
Twyford's own figures show low income households will spend a higher proportion of their income on fuel tax than wealthier households. In fact, on this measure, the poorest 10 per cent of income earners are four times worse off than the wealthiest 10 per cent of income earners.
That's highly regressive.