"I've seen Hayley at some trainings, and Paige was very impressive. They were legends. Girls always get fired up and they do things their own way."
The female bout between Hareb and Holt, a reporter on The Crowd Goes Wild, the Sky Sports news show, was a first for Fight for Life, which promotes the awareness of prostate cancer.
Other match-ups on the night included the headline fight between Betham and Commonwealth cruiserweight champion Shane Cameron, which Cameron won on points, and one between former Vodafone Warrior Awen Guttenbeil and former All Black Carlos Spencer.
Spencer said he was still waiting for the pain to kick in. "I thought I would be a lot sorer - but the alcohol is still kicking. I'll probably be feeling it tomorrow," he said.
Organiser Dean Lonergan said the event had been a success for the Prostate Cancer Foundation, while some of the rugby players showed they could throw decent punches - unlike some other pretenders.
"Liam Messam showed he's got some boxing skills - Sonny Bill Williams would get beat up," Lonergan said. "I'd like to see them box. But Sonny Bill's manager is very hard to deal with, so I don't think they would be keen. If they did - Liam's a better boxer than Sonny Bill."
The final tally was still coming in, but the event looked to have raised more than $100,000, Lonergan said. The main focus was pushing the message for men to get checked up.
It was the two women, however, who proved to be the "superstars" of the night, as Hareb and Holt received a standing ovation after each bruising round.
Lonergan said the fixture had been arranged at the request of Hareb.
"Paige's manager just rang me up out of the blue about six weeks back and said, 'I represent Paige Hareb. She would really like to fight Fight for Life and she would like to fight Hayley Holt.'
"So I rang up Hayley and said, 'This surfer girl wants to have a fight with you. Any idea why?"'
Holt figured she had cut off Hareb while surfing in Raglan, but Hareb said there was no grudge.
"I think Hayley and Dean like to play that up for the media, but I don't actually remember that.
"My manager picked her out, thought it might be someone I could box."
Still, Hareb seemed hungry for more, saying she would keep up the boxing training after losing in a unanimous decision.
"We've had a month of training, compared to Hayley training for three months."
Hareb's boxing coach, Jacob Rapira, said the plan had been for the lighter Hareb to be as small a target as she could be until Holt dropped her hands.
But the fight became a fierce trading of blows as soon as it began.
In a separate charity boxing event on Saturday night, former Wanganui mayor Michael Laws fought Maori Party vice-president Ken Mair.
Laws came out with a bloody nose but drew with Mair in the judges' decision.
That fight was a fundraiser for Christchurch and contributed around $50,000 to earthquake recovery.