The other two pieces were also sold to Kiwis, both from Auckland.
The Weariness of the Aged sold for $257,450. Bidding starting at $150,000 and went up in $10,000 lots. People standing with the female buyer as she examined the painting told the Herald she did not want to talk.
Bidding for the third painting, No Koora te Cigaretti, Portrait of Kapi Kapi, stopped at $175,000 with the highest bidder going into negotiation. The portrait eventually sold for $205,000.
"It was a very good sale and there were good prices for some of the big items," Mr Thomson said.
More than 100 people packed the auction room.
There have been higher prices for Goldie portraits: the centre sold one last November, Kawhena, Johnny Coffin, for $732,800.
In 2010, the centre reached the second highest price, of $573,000, for Forty Winks, which was sold by Dame Kiri Te Kanawa.
Goldie died in in 1947.