Book launches can be a trap for unwary authors. Eager to gain the maximum publicity for their work, they face an ever-present temptation to gild the lily. Done adroitly, this can attract the attention and sales every author wants. Done badly, however, it can detract from the book and the cause it is promoting. That, unfortunately, was the case when Jonathan Boston spoke this week at the launch in Auckland of Child Poverty in New Zealand, which he has written with Simon Chapple.
Dr Boston's mistake was to suggest that the poorest New Zealand children were now no better off than some children in the slums of India. This statement, he said, was based on observations made when he spent a month late last year in Delhi where his wife worked as a volunteer doctor.
"India has about half of the world's poorest children, but there are children in New Zealand living in circumstances that are not that much different from those in the slums of Delhi," he said. "They are in houses that don't have heating, in caravans that don't have running water, and in families that simply don't have enough food of the right kind every day."
It is undeniable that some New Zealand children are living in the circumstances outlined by Dr Boston. But, equally, it is drawing the longest of bows to equate their plight to that of the many, many children living in the sort of slums associated with India. Child mortality statistics from agencies like the World Bank underline this.