"Being a councillor comes with responsibilities, and the first one is that you should attend as many meetings as possible.
"It's a basic responsibility to the ratepayer," Mr Vinsen said.
Councillor Hamish McDouall disagreed, saying he was concerned the issue had become personal, referring to Councillor Michael Laws' poor attendance at meetings. In the first year of this electoral term, Mr Laws attended 10 of a total 36 meetings. He did not attend yesterday's meeting.
"There are many reasons why people have difficulty attending all meetings. I was late today because I had child care issues. Councillor [Clive] Solomon has a busy job as a surgeon. Councillor [Allan] Anderson was away for some time because he was ill. Are we going to penalise these people?" Mr McDouall said.
Councillor Nicki Higgie said council needed to ensure it was as easy as possible for employed people to stand for council, and an attendance-based pay structure might dissuade them from doing so. She also noted that more than half her council work took place away from the council table.
After some discussion, Mr Vinsen's recommendation was put to the vote. Only Mr Vinsen and Councillor Ray Stevens voted for it.