They told Julie Le Clerc that she was too nice to be a MasterChef judge, and she's never forgotten it.
The Auckland Food Show was her chance at to prove she could be a tough cookie too - just like Ray McVinnie, Josh Emmett and Simon Gault. Vowing to bring "a touch of Gordon Ramsay" - minus the swearing - Le Clerc acted as judge for the first showdown between Brett McGregor and Nadia Lim, the 2010 and 2011 winners of the popular TV cooking show, in a creative contest set up by the Herald on Sunday.
But when it came to the crunch, it was Le Clerc, not the contestants, who felt the pressure as she struggled to decide which of the two had created the best dish from Regal Salmon.
McGregor made a Thai-inspired poached salmon salad and Lim served a fruity wood-roasted smoked salmon salad.
"Oh my goodness, this is incredibly hard," Le Clerc said after sampling their dishes, created within 10 minutes of McGregor rushing from a Food Show cooking demonstration.