The touring British and Irish Lions team has been accused of playing conservative rugby, dubbed "Warrenball" after the perceived tactics dreamed up by Kiwi-born coach Warren Gatland.
The sale's lead photo showed Blues player Ihaia West scoring against the Lions earlier in the tour, which the seller said demonstrated to the Lions how it could be done.
With all proceeds going to Kids in the Middle, a charity initiative of Women's Refuge, the winning bidder also received a framed copy photograph of West's try.
If the winning bidder was "English", they would also as an extra special bonus get "a tub of hair gel so you can dress up as your favourite player".
The sale garnered 28,404 views and 35 bids.
It also sparked a flurry of questions - all of which the seller dutifully replied to.
"Is this auction for a 'Lions Test Try against the All Blacks'? Or does such thing only exist in the realm of unicorns, leprechauns, bigfoot, and the Loch Ness monster?" one wag asked.
The seller replied: "Yes! Hey even ole Nessie has been spotted a few times.... But never in NZ waters!"
Another asked: "What year is it? I didn't think the 2017 version was available yet and was still in concept stage?"
"This is a '71 vintage mate... Dusted off for this tour!"
There have been other examples of sports fans dreaming up inventive auctions.
Last year, a supporter of lower league English football team Basingstoke Town FC listed the club on eBay with an opening price of just 99p.
The "publicity stunt" was later removed as the club trended on Twitter.
After England crashed out of the 2006 Football World Cup at the quarterfinals stage, a gleeful Scottish punter put the team on eBay with a mock price-tag of 1966 British pounds.