Ms Barnett said the teenager's body was on the beach for about an hour before police took it away.
The tragedy was a grim reminder of what the local river was capable of.
"We've had quite a lot of rain, and when the Hutt River floods, it really floods," she said.
"We get quite a lot of logs and things caught up in it."
Police are not naming the deceased at this stage. The family has been informed and is requesting privacy.
Police thanked all of the organisations who helped in the search, including LandSAR, the Hutt Community Emergency Response Team and the Upper Hutt Community Rescue.
A friend of the 19-year-old was frantically searching and calling out on the bank of the Hutt River on Thursday after the man went for a late night swim.
Search teams scoured the rain-swollen Hutt River mouth and harbour. Sergeant Anthony Harmer said when one of the teenagers got out of the water he could no longer find his friend.
Greater Wellington Regional Council river ranger Travis Moody said the river was at its peak when the 19-year-old entered the water at about 10pm.
"It gets quite ferocious even in a smaller rain event like that. Any time the river's up you don't want to get in the water.
"It's a raging torrent basically. You'll have big boulders underneath the water moving along with that flow."
Moody said the man would have struggled to keep his head above water in those conditions.
"Even if you did get to the side, you'd have to deal with a whole lot of vegetation.
"It's pretty easy to get pulled under when it's like that, poor guy."
A drone was also used in an attempt to find the teen.
