"What they have is a reasonably steep street but with some sections that are steeper than others. Where as we've got a steep street which is very steep over its entire width."
Stoff believed the measurement of Ffordd Pen Llech was taken around a curve at the inside of the road - providing a far steeper gradient than the centreline.
"So what they've done is they've just cherry-picked a particularly steep section of that street.
"They haven't measured it on the centreline and when you're designing a road, all road design manuals when you're talking about road gradient they measure centreline gradient."
To some that might sound like a conspiracy theory, but RNZ checked with Guinness World Records and it turned out the measurement was taken from the inside verge of the road, which was permitted within the guidelines but provided a huge disadvantage for straight roads like Baldwin St.
To demonstrate the point, Stoff - who is a licensed surveyor for Clark Fortune McDonald - took the measurements of a similarly steep and curvy street in Dunedin.
The gradient on the inside verge of a curve on Lancefield St, in Balaclava across town, was 33.2 per cent - very close to Baldwin St's previously record-holding gradient of 35 per cent.
But taken from the centreline that gradient dropped to only 26 per cent - demonstrating his point about the new record holder in Wales.
Stoff said he did not expect Guinness World Records would change their guidelines, so he proposed another solution.
"They've taken something that's ours - we've got to take it back," he said.
"We've got plenty of unformed legal roads that are probably being used as four-wheel drive tracks that all we'd have to do is go and metal it, seal it over a 10m stretch and we'd get the title back."
Otago University student Ben Russell proposed an even simpler solution.
He issued a call to Dunedinites to show up to Baldwin St on August 1 with all the concrete they can find and pour it down from the top of the street to increase the gradient.
"I was sick yesterday and I thought it might be a good way to not only lift my spirits but see what the rest of the city thinks, and it came off pretty well," he said.
"If you know the Hugh Grant movie The Englishman Who Went Up A Hill But Came Down A Mountain, where actually in Wales they made a hill into a mountain after discovering that the hill beside their town wasn't a mountain. So they trucked a whole lot of dirt up to the top of the hill and sat it down until it became a mountain. That's kind of the inspiration for how it all started."
So far 500 people on social media indicated they would join him and another 2500 said they were interested.
Russell said if the bid was unsuccessful he might take the opposite approach and fly to Wales to flatten their street a bit.
He said only imagination and funds stood in the way of Baldwin St's glory.
Enterprise Dunedin director John Christie said it was great to see just how much Baldwin St's record meant to Dunedin.
"I think there's been a few good suggestions on ways we might be able to get the title back, but I guess it's all going to come down to how much effort do you have to put into getting that title," he said.
"We're certainly very keen to see what the community would come up with and we certainly encourage it."
- RNZ
