But as John Key said of the last Australian election, winning ugly is better than losing tidy.
Ardern will certainly claim a victory of sorts for Labour having closed the gap to a marginal seat.
Its candidate, Shanan Halbert, played to his strength as a local voice, and former candidate.
And while the Greens decided to compete against Labour in the local contest, it appears its supporters actually decided to vote tactically for Labour.
One of the most relieved and jubilant faces at the National function was campaign manager and deputy leader Paula Bennett.
As something of an apprentice to Steven Joyce over several campaigns failure was not an option for her survival.
It was Bridges' first electoral test as National Party leader, and while he didn't pass with flying colours, he passed it well enough.