Three Americans were in on the plan to create the "sand-sanctuary" that allowed a group to knock back a few cold ones despite a strict liquor ban in Coromandel.
In a post to the Tairua ChitChat! Facebook page, photos show the group surrounded by boats, a kayaker and a paddle-boarder.
The group reportedly claimed they were "in international waters" and not subject to the drinking ban.
Time spoke to the organiser of the inventive drinking party, Leon Hayward, who revealed three Americans had been in on the fun.
"We thought it would be a good laugh and the drinking ban would be a grey area if we were on our own island.