"Often after you eat pizza you'll find you don't actually feel that good, but with these pizzas it's remarkable because they're so much more digestible and you don't go away feeling horrible.
And she said you don't have to be plant-based to enjoy the food.
"A lot of people have come in and been really pleasantly surprised and even left not realising we're plant-based, then saying the food is amazing."
Boasting a Mediterranean fusion menu, Nolita offers all the classics from calzone to gnocchi.
Rigby believes it offers the much-needed taste of being abroad, while borders remain shut.
The name is a nod to a neighbourhood in New York, located north of Little Italy.
"So it's sort of a fusion between Wellington, New York and Italy. It's a modern take on Italian food."
Drawing on her own cravings, Suggate said the struggles of every vegan inspired much of the menu.
"When I went vegan I was obsessed with cheese, and I think pizza is the most depressing thing if you don't have cheese on it.
"So being able to nail that and eat pizza again was always the goal."
She said perfecting the stringy sensation came from months of trial and error.
"We've spent months experimenting with different things to try and get a really good tasty plant-based cheese that replicates mozzarella, parmesan, cream cheese, ricotta, feta and even some aged cheeses which we're still working on."
The trio are well-known within the Wellington Hospitality scene. Suggate and Rigby opened Beach Babylon 13 years ago and then went on to launch Little Beer Quarter.
Rigby said opening a business during Covid-19 was "definitely risky" but they were confident in their idea.
"From our experience we know that alcohol-based businesses have been far more affected than food-based businesses and we're confident that this could work in the current environment."
Suggate said that now after five days of being open, they're gearing up for one of Wellington's biggest days of the year.
"It's really given us time to settle in and the kitchen time to catch up on prep ahead of Cuba Dupa this weekend.
"It's our first one so we don't really know what to expect, but if it's anything like the Newtown festival, then it's going to be busy."