Tommy thinks Idol has a role to play

Australian guitarist Tommy Emmanuel has waded into the debate over the value of NZ Idol, saying it can spawn amazing talent as well as lazy stars.

Emmanuel, a graduate of a television talent show, returns to New Zealand next month.

His band The Trailblazers won Showcase '70s, providing the platform from which he built an international career.

"It was a great springboard for me and, on occasion, the TV talent quest can discover some really great talent," Emmanuel said.

Not all the pop elite share his view on the televised talent quest, now in its third season. Kiwi pop stars Boh Runga, Graham Brazier, Neil Finn and Dave Dobbyn recently criticised the format.

Emmanuel pointed to two US Idol winners as having flourished.

"Take Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson. What a fabulous career Kelly is having and she is great. She struck it good in that TV format.

"I don't watch Idol myself but that sort of show teaches you a lot. Like 'You've got this chance so get out there and make the most of it. Here's your moment, what are you going to do?'

"I just don't want the younger generation to think that they don't need experience."

- NZPA