"I said 'I always get in with my tattoos. I'm upstairs [at the bar] a lot'. They said 'You're going to have to take that up with the manager'," Ms Poljak said.
"The manager didn't even say 'Look, I'm really sorry, that's the situation, the rules have just come out, you might have been allowed a couple weeks ago'. There was no niceness about it, it was like 'Nup sorry'. They treated me like crap."
Ms Poljak, who has worked with big name clients including Cate Blanchett, Russell Crowe and Pierce Brosnan, is known for her love of intricate ink.
The makeup artist and cosmetician lives in Coogee and is confused by what she says is the venue's inconsistent admissions policy. After initially being told she wasn't allowed inside at all, management later said she was only permitted in the downstairs dining area, which is popular with families and young children.
"They said 'You're allowed to go to the family section'. I can go downstairs and allow all the kiddies see me tattooed neck to hand but I can't go upstairs with the adults," Ms Poljak said.
"I was dressed nicely, my hair was up. It's not like I looked like I was going to beat someone up or do drugs in the bathroom.
"I'm a regular, I love it there. We've never had any trouble but this time they treated me like s**t.
"I don't care if people don't like my tattoos. I get it all the time, but to actually be turned away from avenue I was treated like that. I should not be cricitised for having neck and hand tattoos," she said.
According to news.com.au, Australian hotel licensees are allowed to deny entry to anyone, as long as they do not breach anti-discrimination laws, and they are not required to provide a reason.
According to the NSW discrimination laws, "unlawful" types of discrimination include treating someone unfairly because of their age, race, sex, disability, sexuality, because someone is transgender or due to their marital or domestic status.
A spokeswoman for Anti-Discrimination NSW said banning patrons from a venue because of a tattoo does not count as discrimination, unless the tattoos are related to a racial or ethnic practice.
Ms Poljak says she has been texting with Mr Hemmes and he has apologised. News.com.au has contacted Merivale for comment but is yet to receive a response.