In 2012, Girgis told Poliwka he had only $5 million of the initial $30 million prize.
Two years later, he launched legal action against the man he entrusted with managing his fortune.
In the Supreme Court last week, Justice John Vaughan ruled Poliwka pay back a percentage of the $3,441,815.50 Girgis claimed he was owed.
The Supreme Court ruled Poliwka must pay back more than $2 million.
Girgis of course is not the only lotto winner to have lost a fortune.
Martyn and Kay Tott from the UK never even cashed in their $5 million winning ticket. Business Insider reports the couple won big but couldn't find the ticket.
Camelot Group, which runs the national lottery, deemed the pair had indeed won but because they did not report the ticket lost within 30 days the money was never paid.