She said her eldest daughter Addison was a very difficult baby who she had trouble bonding with.
"She had colic and would scream from 2 in the afternoon until 2 in the morning. She was really, really hard work," she said of the 9-year-old.
Nowadays, while Addison is more artistic, the mother finds it easier to bond with Kennedie who is more into sports.
However, she assured the hosts no child gets preferential treatment, even if they're favourites.
Viewers could not believe what they were seeing and took to Twitter to express their "disgust" with some even calling the mother cruel.
The mother, however, remains positive that this will not cause any rifts between the children who, she assures, all feel loved.
Are you a parent in New Zealand? We want to hear from you. Join our parenting group on Facebook.