Michael Hill World Violin Competition

By TARA WERNER

TOWN HALL, Auckland - There are two ways of viewing music competitions. They are either destructive gladiatorial events, in which the finalists slog it out to the bitter end, or opportunities to highlight the abilities of some of the world's most talented young musicians under tough examination-like conditions.

Either way, 23-year-old Joseph Lin from the United States, winner of the inaugural Michael Hill World Violin Competition, must have felt he won a musical marathon when he finally came away with top honours.

Eighteen violinists between the ages of 18 and 30 were selected from more than 60 international entrants to compete in the semifinals, held in Queenstown last weekend.

The jury's choice was based on Lin's performance in the semifinals, and his flawless interpretation of the Brahms violin concerto, accompanied by the Auckland Philharmonia under the direction of Miguel Harth-Bedoya, at the Auckland finals on Wednesday night.

He combined drama, technical assurance and musicality in equal proportions throughout the work.

It could be a matter of debate whether his performance in the finals really had the edge over second-placed Russian violinist Tatiana Samouil, aged 26, who was just as impressive.

Samouil's rich, open and warm tone was obvious from the moment she launched into the Tchaikovsky violin concerto. But while her first two movements were note-perfect and very musical, some blemishes in the finale would have affected her chances.

The incredibly gifted Australian violinist Alexandra Osborne, aged 18, came third with a technically brilliant performance of the Shostakovich Violin Concerto No 1. The youngest of the three finalists, she lacks the musical depth that will come with more experience, but is clearly on the brink of an international career.

With a full house responding warmly to each finalist, it was apparent that the Michael Hill World Violin Competition has struck a chord with the Auckland public.

Let's hope that next time a New Zealander finds a place in the lineup of talented young musicians.