"They would take [leggings] into the changing room and they would come out, and I'd look at it and say, 'Actually, this is a little big for you. It's kind of baggy in the knees, the waistband isn't fitting the way it should. You actually probably want to go down a size.' And the guest would say, 'I just don't want something that feels this tight.'"
In the new lineup, getting looser pants shouldn't require going up to a larger size, it should mean finding a pant in the same size that simply is constructed differently. In order to achieve this new range of compression, the retailer said it is introducing a new type of fabric it calls Nulu, which allows for a looser fit.
This comes as the retailer is still trying to shake the bad publicity from the 2013 recall. It has also struggled to update its supply chain and quickly get new items into stores to better compete with a fresh crop of athleisure retailers that are churning out trendy pieces on a tight schedule.
And Lululemon's new strategy, of course, could backfire. The retailer risks confusing shoppers with all of its new pants offerings, said Liz Dunn, chief executive of retail consultancy Talmage Advisors .
"I understand what they're trying to do, I get what the goal is. But it does seem to add a layer of confusion," Talmage said. "And to me, it suggests they're still experiencing a bit of pushback about people's perception of the quality of their pants."
But Lululemon says it is ready to explain "sensations" and the difference between being tight and simply hugged.
"We've done a great amount of training with our educators, and they're all ready and up to speed to be able to have these conversations around feeling - which, it is a new conversation, and we are shifting that," Iamartino said.