The questionable combo has been met with disgust, with one user saying the idea was "horrific", and making another feel "nauseous".
Despite the criticism, some social media users decided to give the combo a try - and fell in love with the result.
But the 41-year-old car racing pro has turned the buzz around his banana sandwich in to a quest to fight world hunger.
After receiving many tweets from those who liked, and even hated his combo, Mr Earnhardt decided to ride the wave and channel the conversation into a positive project.
"The whole thing got me thinking that whether you like the sandwich or not, perhaps we could make something universally positive from this," he said on Twitter.
Launching a two-week awareness campaign, Mr Earnhardt hopes to raise money for the fight against child hunger in America.
Driving like-minded social media users to his website, Mr Earnhardt said the proceeds would go directly to charity 'Blessings in a Backpack', who provided food on the weekends for schoolchildren across the US who might otherwise go hungry.
Mr Earnhardt said that he would match up to $US50,000 in donations.
Donations can be placed until April 23, 2016.
- news.com.au