We finally tracked down Dad, a Jew buried in the psychiatric hospital section of a Catholic cemetery in Brockville – where? – Ontario. What to do with the guilt, the too-lateness. We made a new headstone. When we gathered in Brockville in 2016 to unveil it with as much family as we could muster, my cousin told me it was Father’s Day in Canada.
Not long before this Father’s Day, a friend sent photos. She is a writer who lives here but is from Brockville. She’d read my memoir about Dad, Driving to Treblinka, and promised to visit him. She said, “I finally made it! And, so it seems, I am not the only one...” The photos show the new headstone, on which we set in stone something of the life the Third Reich tried - and almost succeeded - to erase. His children and grandchildren are listed so, as my daughter said, he didn’t have to be alone.
In the photos the top of the headstone is covered with stones in the Jewish tradition, some decorated, left mostly by strangers. There is also a cigar butt at the foot of the headstone. The cemetery’s groundskeeper told my friend a man comes by most days to light a candle and smoke a cigar. Did we know about that? she wondered. We did. My brother’s family lives not far from Brockville. My niece, visiting her grandfather, left a note for the mystery visitor. We met him on our last visit. He’d never known Dad in life. We hugged. I said, “Thank you for taking care of my father.” He whispered, “Your father has been a good friend to me.” Dad, a dedicated smoker, would enjoy the cigar.
Some of the visitors have googled Dad’s name and written to me. One woman said that during her Covid lockdown walk she was drawn to the Star of David on the headstone, glowing in the spring sun.
On Father’s Day I thought about all of that and how relationships end, sometimes tragically, but they don’t have to stop. Lord knows it’s too late to change the past. You can change the narrative that you have about it, or have it changed for you by the kindness of strangers. It’s never too late to try.