Introducing new species is a valuable tool for controlling pests, but although there have been some stunning successes, it can go badly wrong.
New Zealand's approach is to proceed with caution, and many researchers have done and are doing just that. We rely on the EPA (previously ERMA) to be the gatekeepers of introductions; balancing the demand for new organisms to control pests or improve production against the risk of letting in organisms that run amok (think of the kiwifruit catastrophe, PSA).
Using exotic dung beetles to process pastoral dung illustrates the balancing act. Do the risks outweigh the benefits?
The recent debate about releasing 11 exotic dung beetle species in New Zealand has focused on the disease risk to humans, rather than the impact on native New Zealand ecosystems.
I submitted to ERMA against the proposal, arguing that we do not have sufficient evidence to make a decision. In the 10 minutes I was allocated at the hearing, I highlighted my concerns about the ecological consequences of interfering with poorly understood decomposition systems which carry out critically important roles such as nutrient cycling.