Cowell and Silverman share Eric, their 7-year-old son together who was reportedly present during the proposal and despite sources telling People the couple "are both super happy", others have reported another side of the story.
"I know that Simon got her an engagement ring about a year after the pregnancy was announced … but he then put it away in a safe and made it clear that he didn't want to get married after all," shared the source.
"She's a nice middle-class girl and she always wanted to get married. Her mum said that she trusted Simon to 'do the right thing' before Eric was born. Well, she's been waiting a long time – and so has Lauren."
Cowell's longtime colleague hinted the engagement was more about his loved son.