Opinion: Sesame Street was always political

Big Bird. Photo / Supplied

OPINION:

There's a rule in politics or at least there should be: Never get into a fight with Big Bird. You end up spitting out feathers, and the 8-foot fowl just strolls away singing about the alphabet.

In the 2012 election, Mitt Romney repeatedly argued for cutting public-TV subsidies and having the beloved character share the screen with ads — "I'm afraid Big Bird is going to have to get used to Kellogg's Corn Flakes" — opening himself to attacks that he cared more about Wall Street than about "Sesame Street."

In November, Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, became the latest politician to find the big yellow target irresistible. After the Twitter account for Big Bird announced that the character had gotten a COVID-19 vaccine, following a CNN and "Sesame Street" town hall on vaccines for kids, Cruz called the tweet "Government propaganda…for your 5 year old!"

Leave aside the dubious claim that promoting childhood vaccination, a cornerstone of public health and schools, is "propaganda." Disregard how Cruz ignores that Big Bird was promoting the measles vaccine a half-century ago. (Cruz, after all, is the same cultural savant who once considered it a burn to label Democrats "the party of Lisa Simpson.") And forget that, for decades, liberal and conservative parents have loved "Sesame Street" for its noncommercial wholesomeness.

Cruz was at least on to one larger truth: "Sesame Street" is political, and it has been from the beginning.

It is political not in a partisan sense but because the way we teach and protect children — and choose which children to teach and protect — is inevitably bound up in politicized ideas.

This, beyond the fond memories of Bert and Ernie and the Count, is the focus of the sweetly engaging documentary "Street Gang: How We Got to Sesame Street," directed by Marilyn Agrelo, which airs Monday on HBO. Drawing on the book "Street Gang: The Complete History of Sesame Street," by Michael Davis, it uses file footage and new interviews to detail the early years of a puppet revolution.

"Sesame Street," which premiered in 1969, was the project of Joan Ganz Cooney, a TV executive who was originally more interested in the civil rights movement than in education but came to see the connection between the two. "The people who control the system read," she once said, "and the people who make it in the system read." And she believed that the best way to get the kids of the 1960s to read, paradoxically, was through TV.

Her Children's Television Workshop brought together educators and entertainers, including a puppeteer named Jim Henson and director Jon Stone, an idealist attracted to Cooney's idea of closing the literacy gap for inner-city Black children. "I think what drew Dad in really had to do with her political vision," his daughter Kate Stone Lucas says in the documentary. (Stone died in 1997.)

As "Street Gang" lays out, the show's very setting — a city street, not a fantasy castle or picket-fenced house — said something about the range of children it sought to welcome. The racially diverse cast of grown-ups and kids said something. "Sesame Street" was open and public and real, as real as a block where humans hung out with furry monsters could be.

"I saw it as a political show," says Sonia Manzano, who played Maria, because of its casting and its determination to raise conversations that kids' TV wasn't used to having.

Matt Robinson, the first actor to play Gordon, voiced the '70s-era Muppet Roosevelt Franklin, who was created to represent Black children in the audience. Singer Buffy Sainte-Marie nursed a baby while explaining breastfeeding to Big Bird. The Rev. Jesse Jackson led kids in a call-and-response of "I am somebody!"

Big Bird, whose character evolved early on from a goofy oaf to a curious child, has often been the young audience's surrogate, just as he was when he offered up a wing to teach kids about the vaccine. The most memorable and moving example came when Will Lee, the actor who played shopkeeper Mr. Hooper, died. The show wrote the death into an episode, in which Big Bird learned that when people die, they don't come back.

Out of the box, "Sesame Street" was a rara avis: a mass-market hit on public TV, a kids' show with sophistication and a wild countercultural energy. It even surprised the people who made it.

"We're shooting this show, and you see this ugly bird," cameraman Frank Biondo says in the documentary. "I remember thinking, 'Who's gonna watch this [expletive brought to you by the letter S]?'"

But it was not universally loved. A Mississippi state TV commission refused to air "Sesame Street" after complaints about the racially integrated cast. Local commercial affiliates picked up the show, knowing a hit when they saw one, and the board eventually reversed the vote.

It's easy today to feel superior to this racial history or to forget it. When Sesame Street introduced a Korean American Muppet this year, Matt Schlapp, president of the Conservative Political Action Committee, called the addition "insane" on Twitter. "I grew up watching, and it was never about race," he said on Fox News. (Someone inform Roosevelt Franklin.)

"Street Gang" cuts off around the end of the Jim Henson era (Henson died in 1990); Elmo gets just a fleeting glance, and decades of history, including the move of the flagship show to HBO, go unnoted. So the documentary doesn't examine the show's cast and format changes or the question of whether it would or could have been created today, in an era of many more TV options for children (albeit more commercial ones).

But as culture-war skirmishes like Cruz's show, more has changed since "Sesame Street" began than the number of TV outlets. The LBJ-Nixon era that gave us the show was polarized too, yet the series reflected at least some 20th-century consensus about the role of institutions, from government to medicine to TV networks. It was not outlandish that Washington would take a role in teaching kids through the country's most popular mass medium. (Sen. Barry Goldwater of Arizona, once an arch-conservative presidential nominee, was one of the most potent early defenders of "Sesame Street.")

Now, in a time of fractured media and politics, characters from an HBO Max show do a CNN vaccination special that gets zapped on Twitter by a senator looking to score points with the Fox News audience. It's a bigger media universe than when "Sesame Street" first tried to cram the whole world into one block. But we live in smaller and smaller neighborhoods.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.

Written by: James Poniewozik
© 2021 THE NEW YORK TIMES