"There was a lot of nudging and pointing going on from the other patrons but Jagger was left alone.
"He stayed for about 45 minutes but then the place started filling up. It was clear Mick knew it was time to go before he got mobbed and he wandered off down the street."
Jagger was later seen boarding a private boat at Russell Wharf.
"A friend was on the last ferry back to Paihia about 10.30pm and told me she couldn't believe it when she saw Mick Jagger getting into a nearby boat," a local said.
The coast near Russell is littered with homes owned by the rich and famous, including opera singer Dame Kiri Te Kanawa and multi-millionaire businessmen such as Gary Paykel, Trevor Farmer and Craig Turner.
Two days before his appearance in Russell, Jagger was spotted boarding a private chartered helicopter in Auckland.
On the eve of the Stones' gig, legendary guitarist Keith Richards dined with his wife, Patti Hansen, at Auckland's French Cafe.