"Great song, no doubt about it - but I don't believe it's the greatest song of all time," counters Jeremy Wells, who dismisses his co-host's pick as "predictable".
"The greatest song of all time, in my opinion, is We Are the World," Wells reveals, citing the 1985 charity single by the supergroup USA for Africa.
"Written by the great Michael Jackson, in his pre-pedo days, and Lionel Ritchie, who is definitely not a pedo, and produced by the great Quincy Jones. There's no doubt about it. The sales don't lie, it's one of the highest-selling singles of all time. "
This sing-along song raised almost $215 million in today's money for Africa and featured a dazzling array of the world's biggest stars including Stevie Wonder, Bob Dylan, Tina Turner, Cyndi Lauper, Diana Ross, Paul Simon and of course Jackson and Ritchie, among many, many others.
"Look at the artists!" Wells exclaims excitedly. "How could you have a better song?"
"I've hung out with Jerry a lot over the years," Heath says, interrupting. "I've never heard him put that song on at a party. He'll put Welcome to the Jungle on. But I've never heard him put We Are the World on. Never."
"It's a 'go-to' song," Wells says, unfazed. He's confident and unwavering in his selection, but concedes his GOAT's fate is in the hands of the people.
"It'll be interesting," he says. "But the people will decide."
"One thing's for sure," Heath smirks, "the people aren't gonna say We are the World."
So now it's over to you. Vote for your GOAT by texting SONG to 3483 along with your GOAT and you will be in the draw to win a massive $100,000.
You only get one vote so make it count.
The station will countdown the Top 500 voted songs before crowning one the official GOAT, thus ending all music arguments forever. Or, more likely, kick-starting a thousand more ...