Initial reports in the media claimed negotiations broke down because the three judges demanded a 40 per cent pay rise, guaranteeing them $1.5 million each for season 12 of the show.
But Preston this morning denied that was the case and said the trio of judges and Network Ten had agreed on money.
"We'd agree on the offer with Ten," he said on the ABC. "We'd sent a note back to their offer, we'd agreed to the financial terms. We'd agreed to make the next series of MasterChef, and it was the other terms that fell down."
Ten's decision not to renew the judges' contracts for season 12 of MasterChef came less than a week after it was revealed George Calombaris had been slapped with a $200,000 fine after admitting to underpaying staff at his Melbourne restaurants $7.83 million.
Public outrage followed and an ex-staffer from one of his restaurants created a petition urging Ten to sack Calombaris that gained more than 26,000 signatures.
But Preston said on radio this morning the underpayment controversy had no bearing on Ten's decision to look for new judges.
"Ten have been very clear on a couple of occasions that it played no part in their contract negotiations," he said.
"No one said it's George's fault. I'm sure it had nothing to do with it, there's a much bigger picture at play here."
There's been speculation Preston, Mehigan and Calombaris are now exploring TV opportunities with streaming services Netflix and Amazon. But Preston said it would be a "long time" before the trio were back on TV together.
"I think that the next step for us is to drop out of sight for a nice, long time," he said on ABC radio.
"I talked to Gary on the weekend and he was down walking the dog on the beach. That's the next step. I think TV is a something longer term in the future.
"I'll continue to serve out my contract and do what I can and just enjoy the fact I get to do stuff that absolutely terrifies me, like this."
Preston added he didn't hold a grudge against Ten for its decision to look for new judges, and he was eternally grateful for the 11 years he had on the reality show.
"It's weird when you come to the … end of a show like MasterChef," he said. "It's a ridiculous thing to say but you kind of go through denial and anger, but pretty quickly I've transitioned to the point where I look back on 11 years of being on a show, that is an incredible run for any show.
"The same day that the MasterChef news broke … it got pointed out that in the Clarence House review of the year for Charles and Camilla, being on MasterChef was number three on their things they enjoyed," he said.
"Just saying the idea that Prince Charles and Camilla were both on MasterChef, or that we had the Dalai Lama on MasterChef, or that we were the first TV show to film in the general assembly of the UN, which seems also equally surreal and ridiculous, all those things, they're the memories that you go, it's been a great ride."