Additionally, authorities said it appeared the thieves had more burglaries planned. A search of one of the suspect's homes revealed a list of potential targets and their addresses, including James, Davis and Damon, Carranza said. She added that the people on this list have been contacted and warned.
An investigation is ongoing and police expect more arrests to be made.
The alleged thieves described their strategy as "flocking," Carranza said.
"They flock like birds to areas where the rich and famous resided," she said.
Targets were selected "based on social media postings and touring or travel schedules," Carranza said. Using that information, they knew when the homes would likely be empty, she said.
After scouting the homes in their nice shirts and cars, police allege the suspects would switch to a larger vehicle and swap their button-downs for hoodies to carry out the burglary.
"One burglar knocks on the front of the door, testing the premises to see if anybody would answer," Carranza said. If there was no answer, the thieves would enter the home through a window or door and make a beeline for the master bedroom, she said.
They would then "search for specific items" they could "easily carry out," such as money, jewelry, firearms and watches, Carranza said.
She added, "They usually exited the home in minutes, very often taking flight before the alarm company could reach out and notify the homeowner or the police department."
On Thursday, however, when Woods' Woodland Hills home was being broken into while he played against the Minnesota Vikings at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum, a neighbour witnessed the suspects fleeing into their getaway vehicle and called police, Carranza said.
Shortly after, police stopped the vehicle in the south Los Angeles area for an unrelated incident, but noticed a firearm and "what appeared to be stolen property in the vehicle," Carranza said.
Two 19-year-olds, Tyress Williams and Jshawne Daniels, and Damaji Hall, 18, were arrested on suspicion of burglary, police said. Hall's mother, Ashle Hall, 34, was also later arrested on suspicion of grand theft.
The Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office announced Tuesday that Williams was being charged with four felony counts of first-degree residential burglary in connection with breaking into homes owned by Rihanna, Puig, Woods and singer Tota Matthieu.
Williams was arraigned Tuesday and pleaded not guilty, the Associated Press reported. Charges were not immediately filed against the other three suspects who remain in jail, according to the AP.
Over the past two years, there have been a rash of burglaries involving celebrity homes in the Los Angeles area, according to the L.A. Times.
In 2017, Grammy Award-winning singer Alanis Morissette's Brentwood mansion was broken into and $2 million in jewelry was taken, the L.A. Times reported. A month later, NBA guard Nick Young came home from a game against the Orlando Magic to find that his Sherman Oaks home had been burglarised, ESPN reported. According to the L.A. Times, nearly $500,000 in valuables were taken.
More recently, there have also been reports that rappers Wiz Khalifa and Post Malone were hit by thieves.