"Eventually I started a band. And we had quite a prolific high school career," he laughs. "We had three punk bands, all with the same members, on different instruments, and so we made a lot of tapes and a lot of flyers, and made a lot of T-shirts with puff paint, and we played exactly two shows."
He went off to study art when he finished school, gaining a degree in open media and trying his hand at all sorts of disciplines - experimental film, sculpting, mixed media, and eventually was offered a job teaching at middle school in Tulsa.
He proved a little too left-field for the school, teaching about Andy Kaufman, organising an avant-garde art programme and introducing a mixtape club, and was eventually asked to leave.
That proved to be the push he needed to make music a more full-time occupation.
"I have a wife and kids, so I would never have made the decision to leave the teaching position to play music full-time, so it was really lucky that that happened to me."
He'd continued playing music the whole time, collaborating with different people, writing his own material, even recording.
"I'd kind of made a record in the background ... Signs and Signifiers, and that was not really intended to fall into many people's hands, that was more a labour of love, something for myself that I just wanted to complete. But as luck would have it, after my job ended I was given the opportunity to do some touring, and one thing led to another, and I met a manager, and a label, and there you have it."
His teaching career and wide-ranging creative interests still have influences on his particular brand of rock 'n' roll. Films, books and even Shakespeare work their way in - a slightly trippy experience of watching Fraser, thanks to some strong cold medicine, eventually led to a song inspired by Romeo and Juliet.
He also sees plenty of his high school punk enthusiasm influencing the '50s rock 'n' roll style he's become known for.
"I think I was really lucky that there weren't really any specific music scenes in my town as a teenager, so there was no one to tell me that I couldn't listen to punk and rock 'n' roll ... I felt like it was okay to like Eddie Cochran and The Clash so it all kind of flowed together for me. I think I do still play a kind of punk rock - I told someone the other day that we're a punk rock band who care about tone."
Who: JD McPherson
Where and when: Performing at the Tuning Fork on Saturday, February 27
Listen to: Let The Good Times Roll (2015), Signs and Signifiers (2010).