One viewer called it a "stitch-up". Another said it was a "farce". And TV critic Steve Braunias called it "something rotten".
So why was Naz Khanjani eliminated from Dancing With the Stars last night, despite consistently dancing well and landing third place on the judges' scorecards?
Turns out you really do have to text in and vote for your favourites if you want to see them remain in the competition.
Three confirmed to the Herald that judges scores are equally weighted by viewer voting, so even if judges score you well if viewers don't vote, you risk going home.