It was one of the most dramatic moments of The Bachelor NZ's second season - resulting in Fleur walking away in tears and declaring she was "over this".
But a significant continuity fail has raised questions over how exactly things played out.
Tuesday night's episode showed contestants Fleur, Naz, Gabs and Erin sitting with The Bachelor, before Fleur asked to speak with him alone.
More from Spy:
• Chrystal backs fellow 'Bitchelorette'
• Spy's favourite Olympic heroines
At the time, her hair is down, blowing freely in a strong breeze.