The Parihaka Woman by Witi Ihimaera
Vintage $38.99
In the literary equivalent of the old bacchanalian adage, "the second half of the bottle of wine is better than the first", so, too, does Witi Ihimaera's ambitious novel only improve well over halfway through. However, it's a case of too little, too late and the overall impression is of a non-novelistic agenda confusing the work, obstructing the authentic purpose and draining most of the life from the pages of what could have been a reasonably enthralling saga.
The over-arching problem is one of too much explanation and a perception of great expectations - in the author's mind, at least, for this work, post the plagiarism dramas that plagued his last novel, The Trowenna Sea.
He has stated that he sees The Parihaka Woman as a redemption novel of sorts, a foot-noted fiction with a raft of explanation to show source and inspiration. This unfortunately overshadows the narrative and the writing itself and is too self-referential to be the mischievous subtext the writer believes it to be.
The Odyssean saga has the bones of greatness. Using the inspiration of Parihaka and its world-renowned philosophy of peaceful resistance, Ihimaera weaves the tale of two of its inhabitants: the appealingly stout-hearted Erenora and her handsome warrior husband Horitana. When the latter is carted off to prison - first at Mt Cook in Wellington, and finally in a cave on "Peketua Island" (a barely-disguised Ruapuke Island in Foveaux Strait) - Erenora and her sisters head off to locate their respective spouses.