"It's certainly a lot more stable than we saw yesterday, while it's still off those highs it does tell us that the initial moves were a bit knee-jerk so it's trading reasonably well," Lister said.
"A few bargain hunters have been happy to come in and pick a bit up around the $11 mark, which is a bit cheaper than they've seen it for a couple of months now."
Synlait Milk, A2's supplier which also lost ground yesterday, rose 1.9 per cent to $10.50.
Infratil gained 1.9 per cent to $3.275. The company beat its annual earnings guidance and said it expects profitability to increase in the future on the back of its recent investments.
The infrastructure investor reported consolidated underlying earnings before interest, tax, depreciation, amortisation before adjustments for fair value movements, realisations and impairments of $552.4m in the year ended March 31, ahead of $519.5m last year and above its forecast for $510m to $525m, due to associate investment valuations.
"It was in line with expectations and a reasonably solid result. The market is pretty happy with that and comfortable, the question mark for Infratil is what's next on the horizon in terms of investments. They've got plenty of cash, they've got plenty of debt facilities," Lister said.
Sky Network Television rose 1.7 per cent to $2.35 and Vital Healthcare Property Trust gained 1.5 per cent to $2.02.
Pushpay Holdings was the worst performer, down 5.1 per cent to $3.88. The mobile payments app company narrowed its net loss as it doubled revenue in 2018, in line with forecasts. Its net loss was $23.3 million in the year ended March 31, from $25.3m a year earlier, while revenue rose to $70.2m from $34.3m in the prior year.
Pushpay's app has gained traction in the US faith sector, where it is now in use in 54 of the top 100 churches and has transactions of US$3 billion ($4.3b) based on annualised monthly figures.
"It's probably a similar situation to what we've seen with A2 Milk - the numbers look very good, in terms of growth and progress they're making, but it's a stock that's had a very strong run in recent years and expectations have been high, there's a lot of optimism built into the share price," Lister said.
"Market expectation is just a bit too high, you can't necessarily point the finger at the company, but sometimes the market just gets a bit too ambitious in its expectations."
Westpac Banking Corp fell 4.2 per cent to $31.54, Spark New Zealand dropped 2.2 per cent to $3.49, and Comvita declined 1.4 per cent to $6.90.
Outside the benchmark index, Rakon gained 10 per cent to 22 cents. The high-tech components maker returned to a full year profit, benefiting from growth in its core markets and some non-recurring gains.
Briscoe Group was unchanged at $3.50. It will reimburse staff who cashed up at the end of the day but didn't get paid for the time, something managing director Rod Duke says is company policy.