Matt Goodson, Salt Funds Management managing director, said SkyCity's share price movement lately indicated market expectations were "not particularly high" and he had some doubts about the strength of its financial performance.
"There's three things - first is the overall trading conditions and whether New Zealand's economy has been recovering, and particularly Auckland's; second, progress with the convention centre project which doesn't superficially from the outside appear to have been particularly rapid; and third progress on Adelaide and initially that's [about] trading and whether the redevelopment will hit the mark," Goodson said.
An analyst in Australia was more upbeat about the outlook.
Michael Goltsman of Citi Investment Research forecast the strong New Zealand economy to boost earnings at one of the NZX's biggest companies.
"January 2014 trading has been strong, with normalised revenue up 5.4 per cent on the previous corresponding period, thanks to a more buoyant New Zealand economy," Goltsman said.
"Growth is expected across all businesses in the second half of 2014. While Adelaide should benefit from new premium gaming rooms, earnings growth should be restrained in the near-term due to reduced gaming capacity.
"We forecast full year 2014 normalised net profit after tax of $132 million, a 3 per cent drop."
Goltsman has upgraded his rating on the stock from hold to buy, citing the convention centre as a potentially massive money-spinner.
Craigs Investment Partners head of private wealth research Mark Lister said the finance community had been "underwhelmed" by SkyCity's performance lately.
"If I had to pick a couple of companies that are a little lacklustre, I would include SkyCity in that. Things seem to be going slow."
At the interim result announcement a few months ago, managing director Nigel Morrison forecast growth "across all SkyCity businesses" in the second half of 2014 and said trading in January had been pleasing, with revenues above the previous year in all businesses.
SkyCity shares closed down 5c yesterday at $3.55.